November 30, 2010: Scotland’s Patron Saint’s Day (and my son’s) is the Feast of St. Andrew, Founder of the Church in Byzantium, Martyred in Patras, a true fisher of men….

Readers of this blog will know that my son is named Charles Edward Andrew Lincoln, IV, born on August 23 at St. Mary’s Hospital in West Palm Beach, Florida, while the headwinds of Hurricane Andrew were blowing into South Florida.  Luckily for us, up at 223 Atlantic in Palm Beach, Hurricane Andrew was just a severe wind and thunderstorm, hardly noticeable.  But I noticed that all the windows of St. Mary’s Hospital were carefully duck-taped with the Cross of St. Andrew.  As of November 30, Charlie this afternoon observed that the decade that is about to end on December 31, 2010, is his first full calendrical “decade” of life—a strange and interesting and somewhat eerie thought, because my first full calendrical “decade” was January 1, 1961-December 31, 1970….

I have always loved the Cross of St. Andrew, for memories of the beautiful and romantic poetry, history and culture of Scotland (Robert the Bruce, William Wallace, MacBeth, Mary Queen of Scots, James I & VII, Robbie Burns, Sir Walter Scott), and of lost causes—from Bonnie Prince Charlie (for whom Drambuie Liquor was invented during the ’45, which might have driven the Hanoverians out of England, had the man who might have been Charles Edward Stuart III of England not turned back, inexplicably, after reaching Derby in England) to South Carolina and Secession and the Bonnie Blue Flag that Bears a Single Star,  for the Confederate Flags which emblazoned thirteen stars onto that Cross, thus incorporating it in a manner much more elaborate than did the flags of the Southern States of Alabama and, NOT coincidentally, Florida.  Together with last Sunday (November 28) the first Sunday in Advent, today is more or less where the Church Year begins, at least insofar as the Calendar of Saints is Concerned.

To say that the Cross of Saint Andrews for me, as for Millions of Americans and Christians (and many non-Christian or even syncretic pagans who worship the progression of the seasons and honor the division of the world into four quarters) throughout the world, mixes memory and desire like few other symbols is a major understatement.  But rather than try to write anything new about St. Andrew’s Day myself, I just want to quote from an article, almost ten years old, on Lew Rockwell.Com (

St. Andrew’s Cross

by David Dieteman

Joseph Stromberg rightly points out that the media prefers to refer to the St. Andrew’s Cross on the Confederate battle flag as a letter X.

Of course, it is not a letter X. It is a cross — in particular, the St. Andrew’s Cross. In vexillology (the study of flags), the technical term for such a cross is a saltire.  Webster’s Third New International Dictionary (I don’t have the OED on hand; sorry) defines a saltire as: noun, singular:

  1. heraldry: an ordinary consisting of a cross formed by a bend dexter and a bend sinister crossing in the center of the field.
  2. an X-shaped cross: esp. Saint Andrew’s Cross.

The term derives from the Middle English and Middle French words for an X-shaped animal barricade that people could jump over. Presumably, the animals could jump over the middle of the X as well, but it never occurred to them to do so.   Webster’s, by the way, provides an additional definition of a saltire: adj.: shaped like an X.

So perhaps there is nothing sinister going on in the mantra that the Confederate flag is an “X,” but given that the mere reference to “an X” is an incomplete history of flags featuring the St. Andrew’s Cross, and given the larger cultural climate of hatred of all things Christian, I smell a rat.

This is of particular concern to me, as I am a Roman Catholic and a parishioner at, well, wouldn’t you know it — St. Andrew’s.

In the church, there is a statue of St. Andrew himself, holding a big X in his hands. Why? He lived far too long ago to have been a Spike Lee fan or a follower of Malcolm X.  The reason he is holding the X is that it is not an X — it is a cross. Saint Andrew, you see, was crucified on an X-shaped cross.

The St. Andrew’s Cross is not unique to the Confederate battle flag. The reason that the CSA put the St. Andrew’s Cross on its flag is the Scottish heritage of the South.

The Scottish national flag (left), you see, is the St. Andrew’s Cross in white on a field of blue.

(This is to be distinguished from the Scottish government flag (right), the flag of the Scottish monarchy, which features a red lion on a field of yellow.)

A similar situation to the Scottish situation is found in many nations, such as Germany, whose government flag has an eagle in the center of the red, black and gold banner, as does Austria (similar eagle issues).

Joseph Stromberg has brought to my attention the fact that, where the St. Andrew’s Cross is concerned, in South Africa, the Transvaal (South African Republic, or ZAR) flag from 1874-75 (left), known as the Burger flag, descended from the Voortrekker flag of 1836-40 (right).   For those who do not read Afrikaans, Stromberg has provided a translation: “This [Burger flag] is a revised form of the Voortrekker flag. T. F. Burgers, as President of the South African Republic, tried to replace the Transvaal Vierkleur with this flag. From 1875, however, the Vierkleur was the official flag of the ZAR. The Burger flag was however sometimes hoisted next to the Vierkleur in Burgers’s time, and was usually known as the President’s flag.”  (Much like those pesky Mississippians, the South Africans did not want a replacement flag.)

But back to St. Andrew and his cross.

Saint Andrew is also the patron saint of Russia. Unsurprisingly, then, the ensign of the Russian Imperial Navy which flew during the reign of the Czars (left), as well as the Russian Imperial Navy Jack (at right) both feature the St. Andrew’s Cross.

And let’s not forget the flags of Alabama (left) and Florida. (right).

A variant also appears on the Spanish Cross (the Cross of Burgundy, flown from 1516 to 1556 by Charles I of Spain), (below) although I am not sure of any connection. However, since this flag was flown by Cortez in his conquest of Mexico, it is perhaps on the endangered banners list as well.

Given the recent media hysteria over Johnny Hart’s “B.C.” cartoon, and the general media ridicule of all things Christian, is it any wonder that the Confederate battle flag is hated?

The Confederate battle flag (left), by the way, is square.

The navy jack (or ensign, which was carried by some ground troups, as noted by (right) is a rectangle.

The Left certainly hates the Confederate flag because it is “the flag of a stateless nation” that, despite its military surrender, has never surrendered its spirit.

Perhaps the Left also despises the St. Andrew’s Cross because of Andrew’s very name — it means “manly” in Greek. Post-modern, relativist western civilization simply cannot abide the concept of manliness.

April 21, 2001

Mr. Dieteman is an attorney in Erie, Pennsylvania, and a PhD candidate in philosophy at The Catholic University of America.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s